[icon ] blenderdumbass . org [icon star] Reviews

A Sacrifice 2025 is a bit amateurish

October 26, 2025

๐Ÿ‘ 9

https://blenderdumbass.org/reviews/a_sacrifice_2025_is_a_bit_amateurish : ๐Ÿ‘ 1

#ASacrifice #JordanScott #EricBana #film #review #movies #cinemastodon

License:
Creative Commons Attribution Share-Alike

[avatar]by Blender Dumbass

Aka: J.Y. Amihud. A Jewish by blood, multifaceted artist with experience in film-making, visual effects, programming, game development, music and more. A philosopher at heart. An activist for freedom and privacy. Anti-Paternalist. A user of Libre Software. Speaking at least 3 human languages. The writer and director of the 2023 film "Moria's Race" and the lead developer of it's game sequel "Dani's Race".


6 Minute Read



Ridley Scott has a full family of filmmakers. His brother Tony Scott is a legend. But Ridley also has kids. His son Jake Scott is a bad ass music video director that started already branching out into feature films. Luke Scott directed a cool little 2016 sci-fi horror film Morgan. And was a second unit director on a lot of recent Ridley Scott films. And then there is Jordan Scott, Ridley's daughter that wrote and directed the 2025 thriller A Sacrifice. โ†ฉ Reply

Being from a family of film-director's Jordan's use of camera in this film is not bad. She isn't doing anything too exciting, like her uncle Tony. The image is mostly very clean. And we have mostly tripod shots. Either completely static, or with a very basic pan. There are a few moments when the camera becomes a little more free, as in they are using a steady-cam or a gimble to do cool little floating camera shots. The film has a mandatory drug sequence, which is always a bit of a flex for a good director and Jordan makes a very effective, yet kind of minimalist take on the feeling of being high. The only slightly weirdly directed moment was the mandatory night-club scene, where the flashing lights are only white. There is no color. It is kind of strange, in a way. But the scene has an ominous rhythm to it that is quite cool. Also Jordan uses quite a bit of reversed footage for a great effect. โ†ฉ Reply

While the direction of the film is above average ( again she isn't doing anything too exciting like her uncle Tony ), the writing sucks. The premise is not too bad. It is about a psychologist guy who investigates cults. And he is so far up his ass with work that he neglects his teenage daughter. So ironically, she ends up in a cult. This is some cool as basis. But Jordan's script isn't doing much with it. โ†ฉ Reply

To be frank, the movie is trying to be an adaptation of a book called Tokyo by Nicholas Hogg. So it could be that Hogg's writing is what's bad. In any case, the writing is bad. โ†ฉ Reply

With this "she ends up in a cult" thing you could do a cool little thriller. But the movie is a slow burn and not in a good way. The suspense in the film is so non-existent that you kind of feel like you are watching one of those Russian TV melodramas. It goes as slowly as a Nicolas Winding Refn film, but without it being as cool as a Nicolas Winding Refn film. Or at the very least without it looking exciting and colorful, like a Nicolas Winding Refn film. c:0 โ†ฉ Reply

So for example, the film builds towards what could be a little exiting encounter in the end. We have the father ( Eric Banana , who worked with Ridley on Black Hawk Down ) who is this cult investigator psychologist guy. And we have his daughter ( Sadie Sink ) who is secretly meeting this guy played by Jonas Dassler. Now this guy is a part of the cult, where they do Sacrifices. And so the film is building toward this girl being murdered, basically. And the father needs to figure it out and save her in time. โ†ฉ Reply

What happens in the movie though? We get Dassler's character driving her toward the lake, where he gonna drown her as a part of the sacrifice. And in the meantime we have Eric Bana's character driving towards the cult's building itself with his new girlfriend, a policemen, who investigates cult murders. She is played by Sylvia Hoeks who you may remember from Blade Runner 2049 as this cool ass bad replicant lady Luv. Which is by the way a good casting decision for this movie. Because, spoiler alert, the twist is, she is a part of the cult. โ†ฉ Reply

Does the movie reveal it, so it can play with the irony? No. It reveals it, to then use it awkwardly to reveal to the Bana character that they are indeed a cult. And to speed up his reaction, to go save his daughter. So, does he at least saves his daughter from the Dassler character? No. The Dassler character realizes that he loves her, or something, and decided not to kill her. So he just leaves her there on the lake alone. And that is when Jordan, or Hogg or whoever decided that it was a good idea, realized that they have nothing of substance for the father to do here. The girl is safe. All he needs to do is to go and pick her up. So the film invents a problem at the last minute. She starts to see visions in the lake of the previous girl who was sacrificed there. And she starts swimming into the lake, for some reason. I guess to meet that ghost. IDK... Anyway... by the time the father arrives, his daughter is drowning. OMG. Here is something to do. So he dives in and saves her. What a hero, lol. c:0 โ†ฉ Reply

If I would have written it, I would have revealed that Sylvia Hoeks character is a part of the cult, and then not make this information known to the father until the very end. This would create a lot of cool irony. And automatically will make everything a bit tenser. And then not make Dassler character leave her there alone. But instead maybe just make him hesitate longer, to win some time for the plot to get to the point, where the father has to confront him. And at this very point, we already know that his "friend" Sylvia Hoeks character ( who is a cop, and therefore has a gun ) is on the side of the bad guys. Which creates a hell of a tense little situation. c:0 โ†ฉ Reply

But I suppose we got what we got. โ†ฉ Reply

Happy Hacking!!! โ†ฉ Reply

[icon unlike] 0
[icon left]
[icon right]
[icon terminal]
[icon markdown]

Find this post on Mastodon

[avatar]  Troler c:0


The suspense in the film is so non-existent that you kind of feel like you are watching one of those Russian TV melodramas.
โคด View

HAHAHAHAE. I have a hunch what you are talking about.

father Eric Banana


I see what you did there!

The Dassler character realizes that he loves her, or something, and decided not to kill her. So he just leaves her there on the lake alone.
โคด View

That's it? My Michael Bay mind is mushrooming with possibilities of what cool action scenes can be done. Or at least some suspenseful drama.

If I would have written it, I would have revealed that Sylvia Hoeks character is a part of the cult, and then not make this information known to the father until the very end. This would create a lot of cool irony. And automatically will make everything a bit tenser. And then not make Dassler character leave her there alone. But instead maybe just make him hesitate longer, to win some time for the plot to get to the point, where the father has to confront him. And at this very point, we already know that his "friend" Sylvia Hoeks character ( who is a cop, and therefore has a gun ) is on the side of the bad guys. Which creates a hell of a tense little situation.
โคด View

That does sound more interesting. As Robert Mckee observed, a good plot is everything. Or so I recall.

[icon reply]
[icon question]











[icon reviews]A Sacrifice 2025 is a bit amateurish

[thumbnail]

[avatar]  Blender Dumbass

๐Ÿ‘ 9 ๐Ÿ’ฌ 1



Ridley Scott has a full family of filmmakers. His brother Tony Scott is a legend. But Ridley also has kids. His son Jake Scott is a bad ass music video director that started already branching out into feature films. Luke Scott directed a cool little 2016 sci-fi horror film Morgan. And was a second unit director on a lot of recent Ridley Scott films. And then there is Jordan Scott, Ridley's daughter that wrote and directed the 2025 thriller A Sacrifice.


#ASacrifice #JordanScott #EricBana #film #review #movies #cinemastodon


[icon reviews]Basic Instinct 1992 is Verhoeven trying to be De Palma who is trying to be Hitchcock

[thumbnail]

[avatar]  Blender Dumbass

๐Ÿ‘ 14 ๐Ÿ’ฌ 1



It is known that the best films from Alfred Hitchcock were done during the days of the code. The restrictions on nudity and graphic violence gave us iconic Hitchcockian moments like the shower scene in Psycho, where Hitch pulls of a totally kosher psycho-sexual ejaculation of ultra-violence. When the code gave way to the MPAA rating system, Hitchcock didn't really know how to react, producing mediocre films, giving way to directors like Brian De Palma who stepped into his shoes, to give us, more-modern Hitchcockian thrillers like Dressed To Kill. But by the end of the 80s, as De Palma stepped down from this Hitch-immitation role, and before Robert Zemeckis ultimately took this title with his 2000 film What Lies Beneath, there was also Paul Verhoeven and his psycho-sexual thrillers, like 1992 Basic Instinct.


#BasicInstinct #PaulVerhoeven #SharonStone #MichaelDouglas #film #review #movies #cinemastodon


[icon reviews]Trap 2024: oh... M. Night Shyamalan is Back, Baby!

[thumbnail]

[avatar]  Blender Dumbass

๐Ÿ‘ 4 โค 2 ๐Ÿ”„ 1 ๐Ÿ’ฌ 2



We are living in the most exciting era when it comes to M. Night Shyamalan. The era I would call "A lottery". M. Night started strong. Critical acclaim and commercial success hit him hard, when he was a young film-maker. They were calling him "the next Spielberg". Then doubt possessed his sole. Some critics said something about something he did. And there he went. On a downward spiral towards the bottom. The Happening, The Last Airbender, After Earth... M. Night never truly recovered from this turmoil. He did great films since: The Visit, Split, Knock at the Cabin. But he then made strangely not so great films in between: Glass, Old, the strangely The Happening esque ending of Knock at the Cabin. Going today to an M. Night Shyamalan movie is truly a lottery. You never know what you are gonna get. With Trap we all got a fucking jack-pot!


#trap #mnightshyamalan #shyamalan #film #review #movies #cinemastodon


[icon reviews]Kite 2014 attempts to be a Luc Besson film but fails miserably

[thumbnail]

[avatar]  Blender Dumbass

๐Ÿ‘ 23



South African filmmakers, writer Brian Cox ( who directed some bad films himself ) and a director Ralph Ziman decided to try to adopt what appears to be a hentai ( animated pornography ) film from Japan ( with the same name ) into a cool-ass female-empowerment action flick. They even got Samuel L. Jackson ( an objectively good actor ) involved in the project somehow. Yet almost every decision made in the production of this film was a wrong decision.


#kite #film #review #movies #samuelljackson #cinemastodon


[icon codeberg] Powered with BDServer [icon python] Plugins [icon theme] Themes [icon analytics] Analytics [icon email] Contact [icon mastodon] Mastodon
[icon unlock]